SVG
Commentary
National Interest

What Does China鈥檚 Iranian Consulate Mean for America?

Beijing and Tehran both praised the opening of China's consulate in Iran as a step toward further cementing bilateral ties.

ahmad_hashemi
ahmad_hashemi
Research Fellow
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi speaks during cabinet meeting in Tehran, Iran on January 19, 2023. (Iranian Presidency/Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
Caption
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi speaks during cabinet meeting in Tehran, Iran, on January 19, 2023. (Iranian Presidency/Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

On December 21, China officially opened its first consulate general in Bandar Abbas, Iran鈥檚 most important southern sea transportation hub. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and Iran both praised the move as a step towards further  bilateral ties. The Chinese ambassador to Iran  the move as a landmark moment in China-Iran relations, while Iran鈥檚 former ambassador to China said that he  Beijing to play a leading role in developing Iran鈥檚 southern coastal regions.

Why Does the Consulate Matter?

To better understand the importance of this development, one must grasp the bigger picture, starting with the signing of a semi-secretive twenty-five-year strategic cooperation document.

This consulate opening comes after the  of an agreement known as the 鈥淐omprehensive Strategic Partnership between Iran and China鈥� in March 2021, following an initial agreement during Chinese president Xi Jinping鈥檚 visit to Tehran in January 2016.

Though the details of this document have not been made public, according to some , the agreement includes special concessions given to China by Iran, including selling Iranian oil, gas, and petrochemical products at a guaranteed discounted price; the leasing of certain Iranian islands to China; and approving the establishment of a Chinese military base to secure Beijing鈥檚 facilities in Iran鈥檚 restive southern provinces.

To some Iran experts, with the signing of the twenty-five-year deal, Tehran has become a de facto  and is even vulnerable to a demographic change and a massive influx of Chinese nationals. Other pundits  that China鈥檚 endgame is to build an espionage hub in Iran under the agreement.

Could China鈥檚 Military Suppress the Uprising in Iran?

While both counties are determined to expand bilateral ties, the Iranian government faces an unprecedented domestic challenge as the nationwide protests enter their fourth month. The clerical regime has failed to subdue its youth, who seek structural transformation鈥攊.e., regime change鈥攁nd Tehran may need to ask for external support to quell opposition.

There is a precedent for seeking help from foreign fighters and non-Iranian . Indeed, Shia citizens from Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Yemen have been turned into groupings formed by Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps.

Consider the following examples. In early November 2022, it was  that Iraqi Hashd al-Shaabi and Kata鈥檌b Hezbollah forces arrived in Iran, probably to help suppress protesters. In March 2019, a senior Iranian official  that Tehran could use Shia militias from other parts of the Middle East to crack down on popular uprisings in Iran. Amid the protests during the 2009 presidential Iranian election, also known as the Green Movement, Tehran  foreign agents to persecute Iranian protesters.

Nevertheless, the People鈥檚 Liberation Army (PLA) of China is a much harder sell. Iran is aware that deploying the non-Muslim, officially atheist PLA in the streets of Iran could backfire spectacularly. China, too, is quite reluctant to deploy its security forces abroad, let alone in the never-ending conflicts in the Middle East. Yet, as the world鈥檚 , Iran and China can share their expertise, and the CCP may assist the clerical establishment in Iran by providing it with anti-riot equipment and know-how on detecting and tracking Iranian protesters. 

What Brings Communist China and Islamist Iran Together?

Despite initial appearances, both the clerical regime in Iran and the Chinese Communist Party have values that bind them together.

The regimes in Iran and China loathe human rights and see Western democracy as a non-indigenous, invading, and harmful foreign concept. The Chinese development model promises countries like Iran and Arab Gulf states prosperity and economic progress, devoid of headaches such as political opening and human rights. This is why the CCP鈥檚 friends and foes alike are inclined to imitate the Chinese governance model in the Middle East and some other parts of the developing world. If anything, Iran鈥檚 鈥溾� foreign policy orientation and Saudi Arabia鈥檚 recent 鈥淧ivot to Asia鈥� approach show that China鈥檚 rise to prominence has made its alternative, authoritarian development model more fashionable among other developing countries, especially as democracy is in  globally.

Both the Iranian regime and the CCP despise Uncle Sam. Iran and China, along with Russia, seek to weaken what is known as the 鈥淯S-led rules-based world order鈥� under the disguise of advocating for a multipolar world. The China-led multipolar world promises such revisionist countries like Iran an opportunity to play a larger role by diminishing America鈥檚 sole superpower status.

Both Tehran and Beijing have pursued a policy of demographic reengineering. By  Turkic Uighur Muslims with Han Chinese settlers, the CCP plans to gain further political control over the whole Xinjiang region and create a population that is sympathetic to Beijing. Using the same playbook, the clerical regime in Iran seeks to subdue non-Persian ethnic groups by turning them into minorities in their own ethnic heartland via demographic reengineering. In a leaked letter, former Iranian vice president Sayed Mohammad-Ali Abtahi  the forced migration of indigenous Ahwazi Arabs out of Ahwaz (Khuzestan) province and their replacement with non-indigenous but loyal settlers, particularly ethnic Persians.

Is the Consulate a Security Threat to America?

Since 2012, when Xi consolidated control over the party, the CCP has become increasingly assertive in its global military and geopolitical dominance. Not surprisingly, Xi has changed the CCP鈥檚 traditional foreign policy approach, ending 鈥減eaceful ascendance鈥� and seeking superpower status and the eventual replacement of America. 鈥淲olf warrior鈥� diplomacy and the recent  of the combative Zhao Lijian as China鈥檚 chief diplomat, the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)debt trap diplomacy, and  plans to take over Taiwan are some of the changes in China鈥檚 foreign policy approach that either began or gained momentum under Xi鈥檚 reign.

In tandem with its efforts to rapidly achieve global primacy, the CCP  its first overseas military base in Djibouti in 2017,  its first flotilla to the Gulf, and  strategic partnerships with Algeria, Egypt, the United Arab Emirates, and Iran. Xi鈥檚 China has, for the first time, also  multiple naval drills with Russia and Iran. Now, China is reportedly planning to open a military base on the northern shores of the Gulf. While the southern coast of the Arabian Gulf is a US-friendly neighborhood, the northern part (Iran) is a hotbed of anti-Americanism and geopolitical revisionism.

A strong Chinese diplomatic, economic, security, and military presence in the northern part of this crucial waterway is not a welcome development for the United States for a variety of reasons:

The fight for global primacy is intensifying

China鈥檚 traditional foreign policy鈥攌nown as the 鈥減eaceful rise鈥� to great power status鈥攚as replaced by a more assertive one under Xi Jinping. Despite its COVID-19 hiccup, Xi鈥檚 China continues to not-so-peacefully rise to become a global economic and military powerhouse, and its ascent to global prominence poses a security challenge to America鈥檚 supremacy amid the intensified New Cold War between the two superpowers. Skeptics don鈥檛  a scenario where China鈥檚 security goals change, prompting it to engage in systemic conflict with the United States across the world. In that case, the energy-rich Gulf region is going to be a key US-CCP battlefield in the war for global supremacy. The opening of a Chinese consulate in the northern part of the Arabian Gulf can be interpreted as a step in that direction.

Great power competition and dominating two strategic straits

If China decides to engage in systemic conflict with the United States, dominating transportation hubs, strategic canals, waterways, and straits would be key. Strangulating America in the strategic straits of Hormuz and Bab al-Mandab would become essential and is one of China鈥檚 long-term objectives in its competition with the United States. America may have a sizable military presence in the Arabian Gulf region that secures the Strait of Hormuz for now, but as a counterbalancing act, Iran can help China establish its security, intelligence, and military foothold in the Gulf.

As for the Bab al-Mandab Strait, home to one of the world鈥檚 busiest shipping lanes, China already has a military base near the southern part of the strait in Djibouti, and its expansion to the northern part of this strategic waterway would bolster Beijing鈥檚 geopolitical posture. Iran鈥檚 proxy force, the Houthi militias, who are the de facto rulers of Yemen, can help China expand its influence on the northern part of the strait. The new consulate in southern Iran will facilitate China鈥檚 efforts to achieve this goal.

The China-Iran-Russia Triangle

Iran, Russia, and China are increasingly united on the cause of anti-Americanism. They have formed an unofficial 鈥淭riangle Alliance鈥� in Asia that, according to the Iranian parliament鈥檚 National Security and Foreign Policy Committee spokesman,  the 鈥渆nd of the inequitable hegemony of the United States and the West.鈥�

The military aspect of this triangle alliance stands out. Iran, China, and Russia have  at least three joint naval exercises in recent years. Since Russia鈥檚 invasion of Ukraine, military cooperation between Tehran and Moscow has been growing on such a scale that, according to US national security council spokesman John Kirby, Iran has  Russia's top military backer.

In addition, China鈥檚 AI and other military technology capabilities are rapidly developing. Beijing provides Iran with UAVs, whereas Iran sells its Shahed-136 kamikaze drones to Russia. These game-changing weapons are radically altering the military landscape in Ukraine. Conversely, Russia is set to supply Iran with dozens of its Sukhoi Su-35 fighter jets, giving Iran much-needed air superiority capabilities.

China鈥檚 Bandar Abbas consulate would undoubtedly serve as a conduit to consolidate this new triangle alliance.

Coordinating the Belt and Road Initiative

The success of the BRI gives the Xi administration a strategic tool in great power competition. China intends to improve Iran鈥檚 transportation infrastructure by building roads, bridges, ports, factories, and industrial towns, in accordance with the twenty-five-year strategic agreement. When completed, these infrastructural projects in Iran鈥檚 southern free trade zones in Jask and Chabahar would be integrated into China鈥檚 trillion-dollar BRI to export its goods to the Middle Eastern, Central Asian, and European markets. Needless to say, opening a consulate at Iran鈥檚 transportation hub would expedite this integration.

The Reconquista of Taiwan.

If the forceful unification of Ukraine is inevitable for Russian president Vladimir Putin鈥檚 realization of his imperial Novorossiya (New Russia) project, for Xi, the reunification with Taiwan is necessary to fulfill the 鈥淥ne China鈥� objective.

As the world鈥檚 largest energy importer, China seeks to ensure an uninterrupted flow of hydrocarbon resources from Iran, Saudi Arabia, and other Gulf states. By signing comprehensive economic and security agreements with Iran and Saudi Arabia, the Gulf鈥檚 major players, the CCP has taken steps to ensure a smooth flow of oil in the event that the West punishes it for attacking Taiwan.

The opening of a CCP consulate in Iran can serve, among other things, as a platform to ease the energy and economic consequences of this strategic decision.