SVG
Commentary
The Washington Free Beacon

Why Trump Is Perplexed by Putin

mike_watson
mike_watson
Associate Director, Center for the Future of Liberal Society
Russia's President Vladimir Putin greets Chinese President Xi Jinping in Moscow on May 9, 2025. (Mikhail Metzel via Getty Images)
Caption
Russia's President Vladimir Putin greets Chinese President Xi Jinping in Moscow on May 9, 2025. (Mikhail Metzel via Getty Images)

As spring turns to summer and Ukraine鈥檚 Rasputitsa muddy season comes to an end, a dictator鈥檚 thoughts turn to war: Russia has now over 50,000 troops for its impending summer offensive in northeastern Ukraine. Donald Trump, meanwhile, is showing frustration over his stalled campaign for peace. Vladimir Putin "has gone absolutely CRAZY! He is needlessly killing a lot of people," he after two massive Russian missile and drone on Ukrainian cities. This week, he that Putin is "playing with fire!"

Trump鈥檚 frustration is understandable. The president clearly abhors this war鈥檚 human toll and wants it to end. He also wants to pull Russia out of China鈥檚 orbit. But thanks to Putin鈥檚 intransigence, the war rages on and the Russo-Chinese partnership is growing stronger. There may not be a way to "flip" Russia out of China鈥檚 camp right now, and the steps needed to drive Russia to negotiate seriously would likely push that goal out of reach.

Earlier this year, Trump picked up what many in his orbit believed was unfinished business from his first term. An earlier attempt to conciliate Russia ran into many obstacles, such as the oft-repeated calumny that Trump was a Russian agent and the Wagner Group鈥檚 attempt to kill U.S. troops. But his team believed that another attempt to normalize political and economic relations with Russia could reduce China鈥檚 influence there and calm down Eastern Europe.

This feat would be hard to pull off while the war in Ukraine fueled hostility between Russia and the West, and while the Russians mistrusted the United States. Pressuring Ukraine seemed, to many in the administration, like a way to achieve peace and demonstrate American good faith to the Kremlin. The White House also Russia sanctions relief, economic cooperation, and other goodies to reach a deal.

That hasn鈥檛 been enough for Putin, however. The threat of sanctions did not deter him from attacking Ukraine, and the promise to lift sanctions does not seem to appeal to him, either. When Vice President Vance , "If we can't end [the war] we're eventually going to say, you know what? That was worth a try, but we're not doing it anymore," Putin did not hear that he is missing the deal of the century. The implication is that the longer he slow-rolls Trump鈥檚 peace efforts, the likelier Trump is to give him what he really wants鈥攃ontrol over Ukraine.

American presidents have been trying for a quarter-century to get a workable relationship with Putin, and each has failed for good reason. Washington and Moscow have rarely gotten along鈥攖he newly revived Monroe Doctrine was a warning to Russia鈥攁nd the Russian state delights in thwarting and humiliating Americans. During Trump鈥檚 first term, the Kremlin waged a price war against one of America鈥檚 newest and most important strategic assets, the shale oil industry. Immediately after Trump鈥檚 electoral victory last November, Russia鈥檚 state television salacious pictures of Melania.

Russia鈥檚 strategic culture is largely anti-American, and its reading of the global balance of power reinforces those beliefs. No one can guarantee that any offer Trump makes to Putin will outlast the 2028 election, so even a relatively friendly America is still a greater potential threat than China. That could change: Maoist China also loathed the United States, but Mao warmed up to the capitalists when Moscow emerged as a major ideological rival and Russian and Chinese troops fought along their border. Russia could enable a "reverse Kissinger," but that will likely only come if China clearly outpaces the United States or directly threatens Russia.

This leaves Trump with few good options. Better offers to Russia could convince the Kremlin that frustrating the United States and deepening its partnership with China brings greater rewards at a low price, and it could kill any chance of productive trade negotiations with a Europe that would feel betrayed. Imposing costs on Moscow, such as endorsing the sanctions bill winding its way through the Senate and launching a full-fledged campaign to dismantle Russia鈥檚 global influence, could convince Putin to take a deal, but it would not be the kind that pulls Moscow away from Beijing. Putin may decide after the summer鈥檚 fighting to accept some of Trump鈥檚 terms and reconstitute his forces for the next phase of the war. But for Trump, this would be a strategic failure.

Trump has been adamant that this war is Joe Biden鈥檚, and since Biden had little interest in making a Ukrainian victory possible, Trump is dealing with the consequences of his predecessor鈥檚 failure. But until Trump decides what he wants more鈥攁 deal with Putin or an end to this war鈥攈e is likely to twist in the wind.